How to Make a Grilled Cheese Sandwich in Little Alchemy
The best grilled cheese in every state
Cheese heaven
Two slices of bread and some cheese might sound simple but, to many, finding the perfect grilled cheese is an endless (very tasty) mission. There are the purists, who like theirs with handfuls of Cheddar and finished under the grill. Some prefer a sandwich with several types of cheese, while others might want all the loaded extras. Here are the ooziest, most delicious grilled cheese sandwiches in every state. Due to COVID-19, be sure to check local travel restrictions, including state travel advisories, and individual websites for dine-in, takeout and delivery options before you visit.
Alabama: Grilled Cheese, Paramount Bar, Birmingham
paramountbirmingham/Facebook
Paramount is a favourite Birmingham hangout thanks to its well-mixed cocktails, cool industrial décor and fun arcade games. But the most remarkable thing about it, according to many devotees, is its incredible grilled cheese. It's packed with three types of cheese – Cheddar, goats' and mozzarella – layered up with a tangy tomato chutney and packed between slices of sourdough. It goes well with a bowl of chilli and some have described it as the "best ever".
Alaska: Grilled Cheese, Spenard Roadhouse, Anchorage
spenardroadhouse/Facebook
The grilled cheese at Spenard Roadhouse, a casual local joint in the Anchorage neighbourhood of Spenard, has legendary status for many customers. It's delicious as it comes and can also be pimped up with grilled apples and bacon – additions that are highly recommended. The real secret? A blend of sharp Cheddar and havarti cheese, which results in a delicious, melt-in-the-mouth snack.
Arizona: Perfectly Grilled Cheese, Perfect Pear Bistro, Tempe
perfectpearbistro/Facebook
Perfect Pear Bistro has not one grilled cheese but a whole menu section dedicated to them, which goes some way to showing how seriously they take the toasted sandwich here. There's a Mushroom Melt; an Italian-inspired sandwich with pesto and tomatoes; and one with bacon and jalapeño. It's their signature Perfectly Grilled Cheese, though, that gets the most attention, thanks to a blend of four cheeses served with crisp bacon in spiced cinnamon pear bread. There are two locations in Tempe.
Arkansas: Pig Sooie, Hammontrees Grilled Cheese, Fayetteville
One would hope a place with grilled cheese in its name would have some pretty decent, erm, grilled cheeses. And Hammontrees Grilled Cheese doesn't let its diners down. A whole host of takes on the classic include one with brie, Gouda and apple and even a blueberry grilled cheese, made with mascarpone and cream cheese and sandwiched in pound cake. They're all good, but the Pig Sooie, packed with pulled pork, sharp Cheddar and caramelised onions, is the standout.
California: Mac 'n' Cheese Grilled Cheese, The American Grilled Cheese Kitchen, San Francisco
Grilled cheese and craft beer – it's a winning combination. And, in fact, The American Grilled Cheese Kitchen has won several awards for its lauded sandwiches. There's a range of options from a Cubano-inspired grilled cheese with several meats to a kids' version with milder Cheddar. But how could anyone resist a grilled cheese stuffed with mac 'n' cheese? Two American favourites – and double carbs – rolled into one sensational sandwich, with garlic butter to boot. There's a second location in Fort Myers, Florida.
Colorado: Grilled Cheese, Steuben's, Denver
Steubensfoodservice/Facebook
Connecticut: Monger, The Whey Station, Middletown
Grilled cheeses and food trucks go hand-in-hand like grilled cheeses and hungry bellies. And The Whey Station serves one of the best anywhere. Their menu includes the Ella, with brie, prosciutto and fig, and an avocado melt. The signature sandwich is the Monger, with a blend of five – yep, five – cheeses that's also the basis of the other sandwiches. There's also a brick-and-mortar restaurant, brilliantly named Whey Stationary.
Delaware: Cheddar Brie Grilled Cheese, Dogfish Head Brewings & Eats, Rehoboth Beach
DogfishHeadBrewingsAndEats/Facebook
Florida: BBQ Pulled Pork Melt, Ms. Cheezious, Miami
The name is fun to say and the food is fun to eat too. Ms. Cheezious started as a food truck, often named Miami's best, and now has a restaurant in the city's MiMo district. The praise is, at least partly, down to this unbelievably delicious BBQ Pulled Pork Melt, which is a sandwich worth travelling thousands of miles for. The BBQ pulled pork is made in house and is beautifully tender, with the sweetness perfectly balanced by sharp Cheddar and all melted together in one gooey and gorgeous package.
Georgia: Bikini, Cooks & Soldiers, Atlanta
cooksandsoldiers/Facebook
Cooks & Soldiers may call it the Bikini but others call it the best grilled cheese – ever. The restaurant serves Basque food, with perfect tapas like patatas bravas and grilled octopus. Yet it's the Bikini, made with white Cheddar, jamón ibérico and black truffle, that really gets people talking. In fact, these bite-size sandwiches are so good that those who have tried them often can't stop raving about them. It's one of the few mainstays on the menu.
Hawaii: Grilled Cheese, Porky's Kauai, Waimea
Porky's, which started as a food truck on the island of Kauai and has a second shop quite some distance away in Lehi, Utah, is famous for its grilled cheeses loaded with extra toppings. At least, it's famous with anyone who's ever bitten into one of those sandwiches. Because, once someone has tried the Hawaiian-style grilled cheese with muenster and havarti cheeses, pulled pork and a choice of pineapple, grilled onions and/or spicy sauces, no other sandwich will ever compare.
Idaho: Ultimate Meltz, Meltz Extreme Grilled Cheese, Coeur d'Alene
Meltz Extreme isn't only famed for excellent grilled cheese sandwiches – it's famed for some of the best sandwiches in the USA, full stop. Often named among the best casual eateries in the country, this spot has cheese and bread down to a fine art. The Ultimate Meltz is a time-perfected blend of six cheeses – white Cheddar, mozzarella, provolone, fontina, goats' and Gorgonzola. It's got a satisfyingly strong flavour and deliciously gooey.
Illinois: The OG, Cheesie's Pub and Grub, Chicago
A grilled cheese restaurant. We repeat: a grilled cheese restaurant. Chicagoans are famously ravenous, which is why the city has such a rich and eclectic food scene. Cheesie's always offers a grilled cheese of the month, while regulars include a mozzarella-based sandwich and one with mac 'n' cheese. The OG is, of course, the best. A blend of American and Cheddar cheeses in extra-thick Texas toast and with tomato soup to dip it in, this is comfort food at its most delicious.
Indiana: 3 cheese, Subito, Indianapolis
It's hard to work out just how this tiny takeaway spot manages to cram so much into such a small space. Pretty much everything at Subito is made in house, including the sourdough bread that makes the grilled cheese so delicious. The blend of three different cheeses – Cheddar, Swiss and American – is just right. Diners can add soup for dipping (delicious) or bulk up the grilled cheese with added ham (pictured).
Discover the best steakhouse in every state
Iowa: rotating specials, Cheese Bar, Des Moines
Everything about Cheese Bar is cheesy, in the best, ooziest, most delicious ways. The popular Des Moines spot is known for its mac 'n' cheese and raclette, but the grilled cheese – with rotating specials showcasing different local cheeses and complementary ingredients – is always pretty perfect too. People praise the unique flavour combinations and general tastiness.
Kansas: The Monte Cristo, The Wheel Barrel, Topeka
The Wheel Barrel has a huge chunk of its menu dedicated to grilled cheese sandwiches. In fact, it makes up roughly half of the food offering, alongside salads, soups and craft beer. Seasonal specials are offered along with a core menu of sandwiches including The Classic, with a choice of two cheeses, and the best of the lot: The Monte Cristo. It's an unusual but very delicious combo of brie, Swiss cheese, ham, turkey and blackberry jelly, all layered in country white bread dusted with powdered sugar.
Kentucky: Brisket, Momma's Mustard Pickles & BBQ, Louisville
Filling, comforting and packed with smoky, tangy BBQ flavour. That description applies to pretty much everything at Momma's Mustard Pickles & BBQ, including the grilled cheese. This ever-popular diner stuffs its grilled cheese sandwiches with a choice of meats, including turkey, pulled pork, smoked sausage and even meatloaf. The grilled cheese with brisket is especially delicious, with melt-in-the-mouth meat and gorgeously gooey cheese, from a choice of white Cheddar or havarti.
Louisiana: Grilled Cheese, St. James Cheese Company, New Orleans
With two locations – in Uptown and the Warehouse District – St. James Cheese Company has become the big cheesy of the Big Easy. The stores sell artisan cheeses and charcuterie, while the attached restaurants serve gooey goodies including the most delectable grilled cheese. It's the quality of the ingredients that really makes this one stand out from the rest. The perfect sourdough is filled with a two-year aged Cheddar and toasted to achieve the optimum crunch. Not just good, but life-changing.
Maryland: Crabby Melt, Grilled Cheese & Co., various locations
Massachusetts: Green Muenster, Roxy's Grilled Cheese, Boston
roxysgrilledcheese/Facebook
Made with muenster cheese, applewood smoked bacon and house-made guacamole, the Green Muenster is named for the left-field wall at Boston's baseball field, Fenway Park, which is known as "The Green Monster". It's also just a very delicious twist on the typical grilled cheese. Roxy's serves this and other grilled cheese sandwiches from its roving food truck and two restaurants. The best around, according to fans.
Michigan: Madtown Grilled Cheese, HopCat, various locations
The Madtown Grilled Cheese at this sports bar chain is so good, some would pick it as their very last meal. It uses a blend of dill havarti, smoked Gouda and muenster cheeses, sandwiched in sourdough with apple slices, garlic aioli and a drizzle of honey – and it really does live up to the hype. HopCat has several locations in Michigan, including in Detroit and Grand Rapids, and has taken its crave-worthy grilled cheese to other states too.
This is the best sports bar in your state
Minnesota: Jerk, All Square, Minneapolis
The selection of gourmet grilled cheeses at this cute spot is always on point, with specials often created by staff members. The runaway favourite of the core menu, though, is the Jerk – roasted jerk chicken layered with Swiss and provolone cheese, plus a little kick from guava jam. Customers love that it has a satisfying hit of heat. All Square is a place with a purpose too: the restaurant is a social nonprofit that invests money to help formerly incarcerated people become future leaders.
Mississippi: Lump Crab Grilled Cheese, Depot Kitchen & Market, Hattiesburg
It turns out that lump crab, provolone cheese and remoulade sauce is a match made in comfort food heaven. That's how fans of the famous grilled cheese at Depot Kitchen & Market feel, anyway, and it's hard to argue. It's a must. Specials stuffed with meatloaf and their classic grilled cheese, with choices from Tillamook Cheddar to smoked Gouda, are all pretty good too.
Missouri: Royale Grille, The Fountain On Locust, St. Louis
FountainOnLocust/Facebook
Pitched as an "adult grilled cheese" and made with a secret blend that includes white Cheddar, mozzarella and sliced apple on wholegrain, the Royale Grille lives up to its rather grand name. In fact this sandwich at The Fountain On Locust has been described as one of the best ever and "to die for". It pairs well with the soup and, for a truly adult experience, the bar's well-mixed cocktails.
Montana: 1889 Chicken Nacho Grilled Cheese, 1889 Coffee House, Helena
1889coffeehousehelena//Facebook
This cosy little coffee shop serves up a sandwich that's two (or possibly three) comfort foods in one: a Chicken Nacho Grilled Cheese. This ingenious creation at 1889 Coffee House is a tender chicken breast topped with Cheddar, pepper jack and nacho cheeses, with crushed tortilla chips added before it's perfectly crisped on the grill. No wonder it's been described as one of the best ever. The portions are generous too.
Nebraska: Grilled Cheese, Kitchen Table, Omaha
The grilled cheese at Kitchen Table is made with three different varieties of cheese, all melted into deliciously airy and just-so chewy levain sourdough. The bread, especially, is exceptional, and people love the fact everything is freshly made with the best local ingredients. It comes with an equally delicious tomato soup, packed with flavour, and diners can add bacon too.
Nevada: Not Yo Mama's Grilled, Truffles N Bacon Cafe, Las Vegas
trufflesnbaconcafe/Facebook
New Hampshire: BMBC Grilled Cheese, Black Mtn. Burger Co., Lincoln
BlackMtnBurgerCo/Facebook
Black Mtn. Burger Co. clearly takes its grilled cheese seriously – they've even named it with the restaurant's acronym. And they're right to, because this unusual but ingenious combination works beautifully. The BMBC Grilled Cheese takes locally-baked jalapeño bread as its base and fills it with crumbled goats' cheese and house-made sweet onion chutney. It's amazingly delicious and one of the best veggie sandwiches.
New Jersey: build your own, American Melts, Kenilworth
American Melts is a "build your own" grilled cheese bar and the possibilities are both seemingly endless and definitely delicious. Filling options include classic American cheese, bacon, pesto, pickles, sliced apple and portobello mushroom, and diners can choose from different sandwich bases from country white bread to a doughnut. Customers describe the results as the best sandwiches they've ever had, and just a great grilled cheese. There are gluten-free and vegan options too.
New Mexico: Three Cheese, The Grove Cafe & Market, Albuquerque
The Grove Cafe & Market does a classic grilled cheese with a difference, combining white Cheddar, havarti and mature provolone and melting it between slices of crisp, chewy sourdough. It's absolutely delicious and packed with flavour. Diners at this artisanal café recommend the additions too, with caramelised onion, green chile and house-made pickles available to give the grilled cheese extra oomph.
New York: Simple Pleasure, The Cheese Traveler, Albany
TheCheeseTraveler/Facebook
The Cheese Traveler serves up a grilled cheese that really isworth taking a journey for. Its take on the old-school classic is called the Simple Pleasure,and indeed it is, thanks to a glorious gooey blend of Cheddar from Shelburne Farms in Vermont and havarti from Edelweiss, Wisconsin. The bread, sliced from a freshly-baked sandwich loaf, is pretty delicious too, and diners can add extras including bacon and 'nduja.
North Carolina: The Pig Mac, Papi Queso, Charlotte
Papi Queso food truck dishes out the best grilled cheese sandwiches not only in the state, but anywhere. At least, that's how its many devotees feel. The cleverly-named Pig Mac is the top-seller, stuffed with slow-smoked pulled pork, mac 'n' cheese and caramelised onions. It's a firm favourite and we can see why. Other delicious variations include a Bacon Jalapeño and a Mushroom Gruyère grilled cheese. The real secret? Pain de mie, a pillowy soft white bread with a fine crumb that toasts beautifully, especially after being brushed with a mix of butter and mayonnaise.
North Dakota: Ultimate Grill Cheese, Space Aliens Grill & Bar, Bismarck and Fargo
SpaceAliensGrillBarFargo/Facebook
Ohio: Mighty Macaroni, Melt Bar & Grilled, Cleveland
meltbarandgrilled/Facebook
The people at Melt Bar & Grilled don't approach its grilled cheeses the traditional way. Instead, they stuff as much deliciousness in as the bread will take before toasting it all to golden, gooey perfection. There's a breakfast version with bacon and eggs, one with chorizo and potato, and – best of all – the Mighty Macaroni. Homemade mac 'n' cheese is battered and deep-fried before being layered with a cheese sauce and extra melted cheese on top. Yep.
Oklahoma: Macaroni Pony, The Mule, Oklahoma City
The Mule specialises in Moscow mules and grilled cheese sandwiches. For many people, that's basically all they need. Alongside rotating specials, their core menu of "sandies" includes the Macaroni Pony, basically a grilled cheese with macaroni stuffed in. That's not all, though: it also has chipotle BBQ pulled pork and pickles, and comes sandwiched between slices of jalapeño cornbread. They also use three different cheeses in the mac, giving it a satisfying sharpness.
Oregon: vegan, DITTO, Portland
A vegan grilled cheese isn't easy to get right but DITTO manages to serve up a sandwich that isn't just fine – it's the best that can be found anywhere. So say the many fans of this food truck, anyway. The menu rotates regularly but favourites include The Teddy, pictured, with vegan Cheddar, mozzarella and provolone melted in white bread, and the spicier Lilith, which has hot pepper cheese, spring onion cream cheese, vegan bacon and a zingy avocado cream.
Pennsylvania: Short Rib Grilled Cheese, Huda, Philadelphia
Philadelphia may be known for another meat and cheese sandwich, the Philly cheesesteak, but fans of the Short Rib Grilled Cheese at Huda reckon it holds its own. The meat is beautifully tender, the pepper jack cheese wonderfully oozy and the sourdough bread grilled to perfection. This Rittenhouse spot opened in September 2020 and already has a devoted following.
Rhode Island: Gourmet, Scratch Kitchen & Catering, Newport
The "from scratch" ethos of this comfort-food spot means that there isn't one particular grilled cheese that gets customers' pulses racing – it's just any grilled cheese that happens to be on that day's menu. The rotating "Gourmet" grilled cheese at Scratch Kitchen ranges from classic melted cheese with ham to chicken parm and duck confit, described as simply "incredible" by those who have tried them.
South Carolina: The CrabMelt, The Grilled Cheese & Crab Cake Co., Murrells Inlet
The-Grilled-Cheese-and-Crabcake-Co/Facebook
Featured on Guy Fieri'sDiners, Drive-Ins and Dives, The Grilled Cheese & Crab Cake Co. is all about pairing grilled cheese with seafood – and we're down with that. Customers are too, raving about The CrabMelt sandwich: a crab cake squished between two thick slabs of Texas toast with Monterey Jack cheese and slices of tomato. It's the perfect sandwich and pairs wonderfully with the fries seasoned with Old Bay.
South Dakota: Twin Cam, Sickies Garage, various locations
Tennessee: Pimento Mac & Cheese, The Grilled Cheeserie, Nashville
GrilledCheeserieMeltShop/Facebook
The Grilled Cheeserie has three Nashville restaurants and a food truck, and all of them serve up some of the most inventive and flavourful grilled cheese sandwiches around. There's a Pizza Melt, with pepperoni baked into the bread, or diners can build their own. The customer favourite is the Pimento Mac & Cheese, which combines the comfort-food favourite with bacon bits on country white bread. Wonderfully indulgent.
Texas: Barbacoa, Barrio Barista, San Antonio
It stands to reason that the best grilled cheese in Texas should be beefed up with some good old barbecue. Barrio Barista uses tender chipotle-infused barbacoa and layers it up in (of course) thick-sliced Texas toast with avocado and cheese. Diners should be prepared to crave more as soon as they're finished, because it really is that good – and goes perfectly with the tomato soup.
Utah: Grilled Monte Cristo, Cravings Bistro, Pleasant Grove
Cravings Bistro has a tempting array of grilled cheese fillings including the ever-popular Mac 'n' Cheese and its Monte Cristo, which has turkey, ham, Swiss cheese, Dijon mustard and house-made mayonnaise on French bread. It's grilled to the most beautiful golden crisp and comes with raspberry jam, which may sound odd but takes the taste to another level.
Vermont: Custom Grilled Cheese, Hyde Away Inn, Waitsfield
Vermont is famous for great cheese so you'd expect to find some gorgeously gooey creations. The perfectly cooked grilled cheese at the tucked-away Hyde Away Inn doesn't disappoint. It's made with sharp Cheddar cheese from Cabot, melted between braided challah bread. Diners can order it as it comes or bulk it up with any number of additions, from avocado to other regional cheeses.
Virginia: Wine Country, Food For Thought, Williamsburg
FoodForThoughtRestaurant/Facebook
Washington: Flagship Cheese, Beecher's Handmade Cheese, Seattle
It really is the cheese that makes the sandwiches doled out at Beecher's, in Seattle's waterfront Pike Place Market, such a rare treat. Their grilled cheese is made with their very own flagship cheese, made with a blend of Cheddar and Gruyère cultures for a unique nutty flavour. It's all grilled to a glorious golden gooeyness in crisp artisanal bread. And it's utterly delicious. There's also a location at the airport and one in New York's Flatiron District (that's how legendary their grilled cheeses have become).
West Virginia: build your own, Cheese Louise, Morgantown
It all begins with a classic grilled cheese. And it can happily end there, for purists. Or you can build and build until one ends up with a sandwich that's more of a tower, with delicious additions like pepperoni, avocado, buffalo chicken or cheese steak. Customers at Cheese Louise food truck can add on what they like or choose from the revolving specials. Really, though, they're all tasty, thanks to a melted blend of American and muenster cheese.
Check out the best barbecue restaurant in every state
Wisconsin: Stuffed Grilled Cheese, Alchemy, Madison
The Stuffed Grilled Cheese sandwich at Alchemy comes filled with broccoli, roasted carrots, red onion and a coriander pesto. It's highly recommended and is described by diners as "amazing". The Wisconsin cheese – Swiss cheese and Cheddar – is what makes it so delicious, along with the perfectly baked and toasted sourdough bread.
Wyoming: Grilled Cheese, Café Genevieve, Jackson
Be the first to comment
Do you want to comment on this article? You need to be signed in for this feature
How to Make a Grilled Cheese Sandwich in Little Alchemy
Source: https://www.lovefood.com/gallerylist/112386/the-best-grilled-cheese-in-every-state